I took tally of all you kitty (and design) lovers to see which cat scratcher had the top design this year. Natural materials were a big hit in 2007 especially corrugated cardboard. At this time, these two were tied for the most stylish and functional scratching "post" of the year. IMO, the Sweet Kitty Lounge is the sweetest of them all so, if I had another vote to break the tie, that's the one I'd pick. Regardless of the one you crave, all cats need scratchers so hopefully there were some happy cats on Christmas morning!